Writer: Zeb Wells
Artist: Stefano Caselli
I read the crossover story Civil War, and planned on reading, and reviewing the tie-in novels that I had, and although I read them I never got round to reviewing them. I am however hoping to do that now, and am continuing with the this Young Avengers/Runaways tie-in volume, with this being my second trade review on Young Avengers, and first for Runaways.
Plot
After the Runaways are attacked and targeted by S.H.I.E.L.D. the Young Avengers go to lend a hand, but aren't greated with open arms. Meanwhile acting S.H.I.E.L.D. director Maria Hill enlists Warden to track down the Runaways.
Review
This was a great story, and one of the better tie-ins that I've read, with Civil War in general producing some amazing tie-in stories. Zeb Wells did a great job at bringing these two great young groups together, and although I've never read the Runaways before (even though I've heard that they're series' are great), Wells made me love them. He also did a great job of adding drama, and suspense to this story, whilst ultimately keeping it fun, like a young team story should be. Wells also did a great job with the action in this story as well, adding excitement, and entertainment, whilst also allowing it to be slightly gritty, and dynamic at times. The dialogue, and interaction in this story was also spectacularly handled, adding a lot of depth, and more drama to the story. Wells also added an unique twist with the direction he went with this story, which made it even more interesting.
The art on this story was simply amazing, and Stefano Caselli did an outstanding job. The detail in Caselli's art was simply outstanding, with very few imperfections. The layout of Caselli's art was also very dynamic, adding more depth, and drama to the story. I did however feel that the backgrounds were a little plane, with not a lot happening in most of them, but I could easily live with that, as in general his art was spectacular, being very dynamic, and unique. The action sequences also looked amazing, and Caselli added plenty of excitement, and suspense throughout them, with them being very explosive, and entertaining. I also enjoyed how he drew the characters, especially the Runaways, but I didn't feel his style suited Wiccan, as he looked a little squarish at times, which didn't look natural. Caselli did however do a great job at showing the characters emotions, and overall he did an amazing job with this story.
This story starts with the Runaways saving a group of Capekillers from Flag-Smasher, and then getting hunted by other Capekillers for doing so. Due to this S.H.I.E.L.D. acting director Maria Hill enlists Warden to help her. Now I found this to be very interesting, as it showed just how far the Super-Human Registration Act would go, as it's not bad enough that these are kids, but they're being hunted for helping protect S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Capekillers. I was however not surprised with this, and it would be a brilliant catalyst for a great story.
Due to S.H.I.E.L.D. targeting the Runaways the Young Avengers see it as their duty to protect these young heroes, but when the two teams first meet they don't get along well, getting into a fight. This did however give a great explosive fight sequence, adding great excitement, and considering the events leading to this meeting it's natural that the Runaways would feel this way. The interaction between the two teams itself was however amazing, and really entertaining, and I really enjoyed seeing them eventually team-up.
I already mentioned that Maria Hill enlisted the help of Warden, but I thought I'd talk a bit more about what I thought of his appearance in this story. Now I'll start by saying that I'm not overly familiar with Warden bar the basics, but I did find it rather unique by going with him as a villain. I did however love his mentality, as although it's not very pleasant, or nice, it added more depth to the story, making it gritty, and dramatic, also giving us a villain that we want to hate, which is always nice.
The other villain in this story would be rather different, as Warden would use Noh-Varr to track, and capture the Runaways (and subsequently the Young Avengers). I loved seeing Noh-Varr as a bad guy, as having only seen him in Avengers stories, as well as the current Young Avengers series I've only ever seen him as a hero. The action between him, and both the Runaways, and Young Avengers was simply astonishing, being very exciting, and entertaining, and considering his background it was a smart choice having him as a villain, and Wells handled the character perfectly.
Final Verdict
This was an outstanding tie-in story, being one of the best tie-in stories that I've ever read. It had plenty of drama, and suspense, as well as superb action, and tremendous dialogue. It also had great character interaction, and wonderful development, being a tremendously fun, and entertaining read. Due to all this I'd highly recommend this to anyone, but would obviously also recommend the actual Civil War story itself to go with it, as although it's not essential, it is an amazing story, and would give better understanding to the background of this one.
Rating: 9/10
Writer: Kieron Gillen
Artist: Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton
Although this series had a very poor start, last issue was very enjoyable, and shows that the series can become a decent series, and I seriously hope that this promise continues in the next few issues, and hopefully even beyond that.
Plot
With Loki betraying them, the Young Avengers are left to face their parents alone. Meanwhile Loki has a fight with his conscience over whether to return and help the Young Avengers.
Review
Following a very enjoyable last issue, the first story arc in the new Young Avengers series ended on a relative high note, and although the series is still a little of the level of quality that I'd hoped for, this along with the last issue has shown promise for the series. Kieron Gillen has certainly improved the quality of his work on this series, and although his Iron Man series is still slightly poor, he's starting to show that he's still the great writer that brought us the fabulous Journey into Mystery. Gillen did a brilliant job of showing that this series could be fun, and entertaining throughout this issue, and although it's still far from being perfect, it is a vast improvement, on the slow, and dull pacing the first few issues had. Gillen also did a fantastic job with the action in this issue, as it was very exciting, and entertaining, adding more drama, and suspense to the story, which was brilliant. I also liked how Gillen didn't add as much humour to this issue, and the humour that was added was very funny, and appropriate, whereas in the past it has felt slightly forced, and unnecessary. I also loved how despite all the fun, and excitement that went on in this issue, that Gillen still made room to continue developing the character's emotions, and it really added more depth to the issue, whilst also yet again adding more drama.
The art from Jamie McKelvie, and Mike Norton was once again brilliant, and their art on this issue has probably been their best in the series so far. To be honest the art has been what's impressed me the most about this series, as it's so unique, and different that it really grabs my attention, and even when the story's poor, the art always pleases, and just seems to get better, and better. One of the things that I love the most about McKelvie, and Norton's artwork is they layouts, which are spectacular, and really add another level of awesomeness to the series, whilst also making it much more dynamic. Besides that the character's are also drawn perfectly, and the style really suits the series, being very fun, and vibrant. The detail in the artwork was also brilliant, and the character's facial expressions were handled perfectly, with their emotions being easy to understand. The art on the action sequences was also nothing short of phenomenal, as it really made the sequences feel that much more dramatic, adding a lot more impact to them, as well as more excitement.
Now the rest of my review may not be as long as usual, as due to there being less happening in this issue, along with the fact that I don't want to give away any major spoilers makes it hard to write a review at the length I usually write. Anyway lets start with how the Young Avengers dealt with Loki's betrayal, and how Wiccan blamed himself for this. The betrayal by Loki in last issue was a shock, but not a surprsise, as although I knew Loki was up to something I didn't think he'd blatantly betray them, although it is Loki after all. I did enjoy the way the Young Avengers reacted to this, seeing themselves as sitting ducks, but it was the depressing reaction Wiccan had that I enjoyed the most, as it was full of emotion, and made you feel for him, as although you could say that he shouldn't be so emotional, it's understandable considering the circumstances.
As Loki was away he was meditating, and getting bugged by his conscience, which resembled the younger Loki. For people who didn't read Journey into Mystery, the younger Loki swallowed Ikol (which possessed the spirit of the evil Loki) to save Asgard, allowing evil Loki to once again walk among us. I loved how the young Loki still resides in his body featuring as a conscience, as although this feels awful similar to what happened with Peter Parker in Superior Spider-Man, it was nice to see that the younger Loki wasn't forgotten, and that he will still play a role in Loki's life, by making him feel guilty about his actions. I did however also love how unlike with Superior Spider-Man both the conscience of young Loki, and the evil version that's in control of the body got to interact, which made it much more fun, and interesting. This did however beg the question whether this would cause Loki to have a change of heart, and return and help the Young Avengers, but I won't answer that to avoid spoilers.
The issue would however see the Young Avengers have it all out against the group of parents, and although I won't reveal as to the outcome of the fight, or any details, I will say what I though of it, and whether it was a worthy fight to end the first story arc. Now the fight was epic, and very exciting. I really enjoyed how each member managed to bring their all, and along with the amazing art, it was truly amazing. I did however find the ending to be a bit abrupt, as although I won't say any details as to avoid spoilers, it was a bit unexpected, and kind of ruined the rest of the fight, which was a shame.
Final Verdict
This series is still far from being at the level I hoped it'd be, but it deviantly's showing improvement, and this was a very exciting, and entertaining issue. It was also very emotional at times, and had brilliant action, and although there were a couple of disappointing factors involved in this issue, in general it was very good, and I hope this is a sign of things to come. I would highly recommend this issue as although not perfect it was still very good, but if you've not been following the series it may be better to wait until the next issue, as this was the end of a story, and may be confusing without the other issues.
Rating: 4/5
Writer: Allan Heinberg
Artists: Jim Cheung, Andrea Divito, Neal Adams, Pasqual Ferry, Michael Gaydos, Gene Ha, Jae Lee & Bill Sienkiewicz
I was never really a fan of the Young Avengers, as although they looked interesting they never really appeared in anything that overly interested me, but after deciding to get the new Young Avengers series, as well as having always wanted to get the Avengers: The Children's Crusade, I decided to get this, as I've heard a lot of good things about it. I also plan on getting the other Young Avengers mini-series that have been out, and review them as well.
Plots
Sidekicks
When the Avengers split up (see Avengers Disassembled) a new group of "Young Avengers", consisting of Iron Lad, Patriot (Eli Bradley), Asgardian (Billy Kaplan), and Hulkling (Teddy Altman) appear, eventually being joined by Kate Bishop, who's the daughter of publishing magnate Derek Bishop, and Cassie Lang, the daughter of the late Avenger, Ant-Man (Scott Lang). Captain America, Iron Man, and Jessica Jones however aren't happy about these young superhero's and try to put a stop to them. There's also room for Kang to be somehow involved.
Secret Identities
Although Cap forbids them from wearing their uniforms again, the Young Avengers continue to act as a team, sporting new uniforms, but when the come across Mr. Hyde there's a secret from Patriot that will shock the group.
Family Matters
After deciding to disband the Young Avengers can't help but want to be hero's, and when they gather to discuss whether they should continue being hero's Hulkling is attacked by Super-Skrull. Also a new Young Avenger named Tommy Shepherd, who'd later be known as Speed makes his début.
Review
This was a phenomenal book, and one of the best Ultimate Collections that I have ever bought. Although I have never read any of Allan Heinberg's work in the past he really did a tremendous job with this book, and the entire series was truly magical. Talking about magic, the way he managed to add magic in a fun, and interesting way was one of the things that I loved most about the series as a whole, as although magic has been a subject that has featured heavily in comics over the years, as well as in the Young Avengers, the subtle way he did it in this story was amazing, and although the series wasn't fully magic oriented, the magic that was involved was spectacular. The emotion, and character development that Heinberg put into this series was also amazing, and it's hard to easily think of a series, or story that has been quite as perfect as this, as although there have been many better stories than any of these, there isn't many series that are this perfect all the way through. I also loved how Heinberg managed to balance out the development of the series with the brilliant action, and epic appearances as if it wasn't done as good as it was I'd have thought that the big name appearances would have been just for the sake of adding big names to draw in readers, but the way Heinberg handled this, as well as everything else was brilliant. The way that Heinberg was able to create all these then new characters, as well as giving them a connection to the Avengers, as well as something unique, and interesting was also amazingly done, and this was probably the thing that stood out the most to me in his writing, which was overall outstandingly brilliant.
The art was no less perfect than the writing, as Jim Cheung did a outstanding job, making everything look beautiful. Although I've seen Cheung's work in the past, on posters, and comic covers I haven't really seen a lot of it in comics, so was very happy to have seen it in this. His art was truly wonderful, and really suited Heinberg's stories, as it was very dynamic. The way that Cheung designed the new character's was also brilliant, and very clever, and I loved the way he managed to make similarities with well known Avengers whilst also making them unique. I also loved the fact that this book gave the extra at the back showing his character design sketches, which were brilliant in themselves. The way Cheung laid out his art was also outstanding, adding a lot of drama, and excitement to a series that already had plenty, which was brilliant. The detail in Cheung's art was also tremendously handled, as everything looks perfect, with the small details even looking fabulous, and there was only one panel of his art that I felt could have been done a bit better, which is saying something for the amount of art that Cheung produced. If all this wasn't good enough, the thing that really stood out to me was the way he drew the action sequences, as they were nothing short of epic, and truly outstanding, as was all his art. There was also other artists work featured in this book, with multiple artists working on the Young Avengers Special issue, including the likes of Pasqual Ferry, Jae Lee, Bill Sienkiewicz, and others, as well as Andrea Divito working on the Secret Identities story. All their work was excellent, and although none of their art was as good as Cheung's, they all did an amazing job, especially Lee, Divito, and Ferry. The colours from Justin Ponsor were also outstanding, and really suited all the artwork, making it much more vibrant, and lively.
Now I usually talk about certain things I liked throughout the graphic novel, or comic at this point, but due to this being a collection of three stories I felt that it'd be appropriate to talk about them individually, also rating them individually. I won't however be taking more on the writer, and artists unless absolutely necessary, as I've talked about there work in general throughout this entire book, and feel it unnecessary to add anything more.
Sidekicks
Obviously with this being the first story to feature the Young Avengers, it was also the story to introduce them, and the way Heinberg did that was brilliant. I just loved how when the Avengers disassemble for a team consisting of mainly completely new characters to have them shown right from the start as a team was brilliant, and I think the story would have been much slower, and dull if they opened the series by introducing the characters one by one, as Heinberg would go onto develop the backgrounds of the characters, and how they became a team later. The team itself was also amazing, and although I've been enjoying seeing the members that are still part of the team in the new series, to see the original team, and how they interacted with each other was nice, and I much prefer this team, especially considering they all have clashing personalities, as well as resemblances to previous Avengers. My personal favourite Young Avenger is Kate Bishop, and always has been, but after reading this I actually like a lot of these character's, especially Iron Lad, who was very interesting, and well developed, and this story wouldn't have worked without him.
With the introduction of a new team of Avengers it was bound to draw the attention of former Avengers, especially the ever righteous Captain America. I also found the fact that Iron Man was with Cap predictable, but to have Jessica Jones also alongside them was however very surprising, and interesting, although after thinking about it, as well as Heinberg giving a brilliant reason it really does make sense, and is appropriate. Anyway besides this these three aren't happy about these Young Avengers being a team, seeing them as too young. Besides the fact this makes for an interesting side plot, that would continue throughout the series, I did however question the right of Cap to question about these kids being superhero's, as he had Bucky Barnes who was only a teenager at the time working besides him. At the same time you could also use this as a reason for Cap's decision, as the fate of Bucky wasn't pleasant. Besides all that the difference of opinions between the Young Avengers, and Cap were interesting, and when they finally confronted one another it made for a really dramatic sequence.
Another thing that would be shown during this story would be relationships between certain members, with some being more obvious than others. I'll start with the one that I know would become a proper relationship, and in fact it happened not long during this series, and although I knew of it before hand it was still pretty obvious before being officially revealed, and that was the relationship between Billy, and Teddy. The way Heinberg handled this relationship was brilliant, as although gay relationships aren't a new thing in comics, there have been some that I have felt have been a bit forced, not really working, whereas the chemistry between these two characters is perfect, and their love for one another really showed through in this story, as well as the entire series. This wasn't the only relationship, or questionable possible relationship to feature in this story, as Iron Lad, and Cassie would share a kiss, and there was also some romantic tension between Eli, and Kate. Now the other two seemed a little sudden, as it seemed just an excuse to give everyone someone to care for, and although that was nice I feel it would have been more realistic to have a couple with no obvious, or questionable love interests. I did however like how Heinberg didn't actually make Eli, and Kate a couple, as the tease was nice, but due to them both being strong willed characters it's something that wouldn't just happen quickly.
As if this story wouldn't be good enough, Kang the Conqueror would be involved. Now I won't go into any details over Kang's appearance, as it contains huge spoilers over the story, as people who have read this story, or about it will know anyway. The appearance of Kang always has me excited, but that also leaves a lot of expectations, which sometimes aren't met. This wasn't the case this time however, as Kang was brilliant in this story, and the way Heinberg involved him was not just interesting, but unique, and genius. The way Kang interacted with both the Young Avengers, as well as Cap, Iron Man, and Jessica Jones was also very interesting, and the fighting that would happen throughout this story involving Kang was epic, and really entertaining, and although Heinberg's script was perfect, it was Cheung's art that blew me away.
Verdict
A brilliant opening story that introduces these Young Avengers perfectly. The story itself was also very interesting, and entertaining, as well as being exciting. The drama, and suspense that would go throughout was also brilliant, and overall it was a truly brilliant story, and would make anyone a Young Avengers fan.
Rating: 5/5
Secret Identities
Now this was a much shorter story, so obviously the review for it will be smaller as well. The main development in this story was the reveal of a secret of Patriot's. Now I won't spoil what this secret is, as it'd ruin the whole story, but it was shocking, as having not read up on the character prior to this I didn't know about it, making it a total surprise. Besides that the way Heinberg handled it was simply perfect, something that he's seemed to do with almost everything in this series, as he made it really dramatic, and suspenseful, as well as surprising, and emotional. I also loved the way the other Young Avengers reacted to this secret, and overall it was simply brilliant, and a big thing to add to the series, especially at the point it was added.
This story also featured Mr. Hyde, a villain that isn't used as much as I'd like, and when he is used it's usually not in a good way. The way Hyde was added to this story was however brilliant, and it really helped to develop the secret of Patriots at a quicker pace. I also felt that having Hyde as the villain for younger, and inexperienced character's is perfect, as it allows him to be so much more of a threat, as if you put him on his own against the normal Avengers unless the writer was very creative he'd only last minutes, but with these character's he was a much more impactful force. The Young Avengers weren't no pushover though, as they brought the fight to Hyde, making it very entertaining, and exciting, as well as interesting.
This story would be followed by a one-shot extra sized Young Avengers Special issue, which would see Jessica Jones talking to the Young Avengers, learning how they got their powers. Although not a necessary issue to enjoy the series, this was a nice addition, and a really enjoyable read, and the way the origins of these characters was told was brilliant, and although some of the origins were obviously more exciting, or interesting than others, they were all brilliant. The fact that they were telling them to a relatively neutral party was also interesting, as although Jessica has been trying to make sure that these Young Avengers are safe, she hasn't went full out saying that they shouldn't be hero's.
Verdict
Although not quite as good as the opening story, this was still a phenomenal story, with a lot of emotion, and excitement, and if it wasn't for the fact it was so short it could have even been better than the first story. At the same time if it was longer it could also have been worse, so it's best just to be thankful that it was this good, as it was really entertaining.
Rating: 5/5
Family Matters
This story was phenomenal, and probably my favourite in the entire series, and a great way to finish. The story itself starts with the Young Avengers disbanding, but when they soon meet up to discuss if this is the right thing Hulkling is kidnapped by the Super- Skrull. Before I get to the Super-Skrull's involvement it's only natural, and right to talk about the Young Avengers disbanding, even if it only proved to be very temporary. To be fair as the series was progressing it was obvious that it would happen, so the fact that it did didn't surprise me, especially after the events that preceded this. At the same time I also loved how Heinberg basically put them back together straight away, as although that sort of thing doesn't usually appeal to me, with these character's it does, as they clearly have the will to be superhero's, and it took a lot to make them disband, so it was natural that most of them, if not all of them would question whether it was the right thing.
Back to the appearance of the Super-Skrull. In most occasions I'd class a sudden attack by such a powerful character to be unrealistic, and forced, feeling that they're done solely to add more action, and excitement to the story, but in this case I don't think that as like everything Heinberg's done in this series, he's handled this well, giving a brilliant reason, and to be honest even if he didn't, this story was that good that it wouldn't have mattered to me anyway. Anyway the reasoning for Super-Skrull's appearance is that he's on Earth to take the heir of the Skrull Empire back to their home world, and Super-Skrull believes Hulkling to be that person. Now although I won't fully reveal whether this is true or not to avoid spoilers, as most people who know anything about Hulkiling will know is that he's a shape-shifter, so this would be an obvious theory as to why he's a shape-shifter, also making for an interesting story. I also loved that like the way Kang was added into a prior story, this was a brilliant way to add yet another high profile villain in Super-Skrull. Another thing I liked about the Super-Skrull's appearance was that besides all the fighting he was involved in, we also got to learn a little more about him, and his character, making the story more dramatic.
As if the addition of the Super-Skrull wasn't enough the Kree would also make an appearance. Now it's not unusual for the Skrull's, and Kree to feature in the same story, and there's usually a fifty percent chance that they will, as the Kree/Skrull War has influenced the Marvel Universe for years. Anyway although I won't go into details about the Kree's reason for making an appearance, as to avoid spoilers, I will say my feelings on the matter, as well as a few other things. To be honest if it wasn't for the fact that they were necessary for the story, as well as being involved in epic action, I could have lived without the Kree in this story, but for them reasons I loved their appearance, and although the dialogue from the Kree wasn't the best it could have been, Heinberg made up for this in so many other areas. With the Kree's involvement, as well as the Avengers connection, Captain Marvel was also brought up in the story, and although I won't go into details, I'll yet again say how nice it was, and although Captain Marvel didn't actually appear himself, it was a nice reference.
This story would also see the introduction of the final Young Avenger to feature in this series, and a character that would become well known as a valuable member of the team. Obviously I'm talking about Tommy Shepherd, who'd later be known as Speed, with the power of super speed , as well as the ability to cause explosions. Before I read anything to do with the Young Avengers it was Speed, and Wiccan that interested me the most, so to finally get to read a story that involves him was nice. Having read-up on the character I know that it was highly speculated that he, along with Wiccan was the son of the Scarlet Witch, which was the main thing that interested me about the character's in the first place, and this story would also be the first to mention this, which was nice. Besides that I found Speed a very interesting character, and loved how there was yet another different set of characteristics in the mix, as the fact all these character's have been so unique is one of the things I've loved the most about this series. The way that Speed was introduced as a criminal was also very interesting, as was the way he interacted with his teammates and overall I found him a very interesting character, and look forward to seeing more of him in the other Young Avengers stories I have to read.
This story would also see the first time the Young Avengers teamed with the New Avengers, also being the only time in this series. With Cap being all against the Young Avengers being a team it was nice to see him, and his then newly assembled New Avengers team with our young hero's, and if there wasn't already enough brilliant things in this series this would definitely make the series phenomenal. The way the Young Avengers interacted with the other members of the New Avengers was brilliant, and I especially liked how Wolverine, and Speed got along, and the dialogue between the two, as well as the other interactions was pure perfection. The way they all worked as one giant team, and the fact that Hulkling of the Young Avengers got to shout the famous, "Avengers Assemble," line also made this one of the best team-ups I've ever seen, especially between two different groups.
Verdict
This story was truly epic, and Heinberg really did leave the best to last. The story itself was enough to be a brilliant story, but with all the additional appearances, as well as the fabulous action, and the way it was all pieced together really made this a phenomenal story, and it was the perfect way to end such an amazing series.
Rating: 5/5
Final Verdict
This was an amazing book, and one of the best reads I've had in years, and I'm really kicking myself for having not read this earlier. The action, magic, entertainment, and emotion that oozes though this series was brilliant, and this book was a true masterpiece. The character development was some of the best I've ever seen, and the series did a phenomenal job of managing to be both fun, and serious, whilst also managing to be exciting. Basically this was an epic book, and should be at least tried by everyone, as I for one am annoyed that I hadn't read it sooner, and would highly recommend it to anyone.
Overall Rating: 5/5
The next book to feature the Young Avengers that I'll be reviewing will be Civil War: Young Avengers and Runaways.
Before that however I'll be reviewing Civil War itself.
Writer: Kieron Gillen
Artists: Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton
Before this series started I was really looking forward to it as the teaser in the Marvel NOW! Point One issue was brilliant, but unfortunately it's been disappointing. I do however have faith that this series will become good, but if it's not consistently good, or at least interesting in the next story I may be dropping it.
Plot
Kate Bishop, and Noh-Varr return to help the rest of these Young Avengers, and after a visit from Noh-Varr's parents the question remains, can the Young Avengers trust Loki?
Review
This was surprisingly a very enjoyable issue, and if it continues like this there may be a lot of hope for the future of this series. To be fair this story has been very dull, and although this issue has been much better than the previous issues in the story I doubt I will have fond memories of it. Kieron Gillen hasn't really been doing well in Marvel NOW! so far, as both this series and Iron Man (which I dropped after the first story) have not really appealed to me, so it was nice to see him do good on this issue. Now this issue wasn't without it's flaws, and there were moments were it could have easily have been as poor as the last couple of issues, but Gillen did manage to give the fun vibe that I hope for in this type of series, as well as shock, and interest. I still think the whole foundations of this story with the weird parents isn't good, and can't wait for it too finish, but I am glad that it's at least exciting, and fun, with some humour, and amazing action. Gillen also surprising gave some brilliant emotion, as although he's shown that he can do this in previous series like Journey into Mystery he hasn't really done it that much in this series.
The art from Jamie McKelvie, and Mike Norton was once again amazing, and although I'm still not 100% sure on how the art's split between the two it doesn't stop it from being amazing. The detail in the artwork is brilliant, as everything looks perfect, whether small, or large details. The style of artwork that McKelvie, and Norton use on this series suits it brilliantly, as the cartoonish style helps to give more of a fun atmosphere to the series, which it needs. I also love the way it's laid out, and especially in the double page that shows Noh-Varr's actions in M.J's Nightclub. I also love how the characters themselves are drawn, as they look brilliant, and the facial expressions are handled brilliantly, adding more drama, and suspense to the issue. The action was also fabulously handled, being very dynamic, and entertaining, and overall McKelvie, and Norton did an amazing job. Matthew Wilson also did a brilliant job with the colouring, and they really suit the tone of the series, making McKelvie, and Norton's art look even more fun.
The main thing I was looking forward to with this issue was the return of Kate, and Noh-Varr to the series having not made an appearance since the first issue. I was a bit disappointed that they hadn't been involved as with Kate being my favourite of the Young Avengers, and also finding Noh-Varr's addition intriguing, it's been a shame that they haven't appeared, and although I've not minded seeing the focus Wiccan, Hulkling, Ms. America, and Loki, I'd have preferred if they'd been included. Anyway, they come back to the series in a big way, bringing ton's of excitement with them, and now that the whole of the Young Avengers are together this series may finally become something brilliant.
When Kate, and Noh-Varr reach the Young Avengers at M.J.'s Nightclub, Noh-Varr makes a brilliant entrance, crashing through the window, and attacking the weird creatures that appear to be the Young Avengers parents. Now there'll be a lot of people that will find this sequence a little too cheesy, but I enjoyed it, and the way the double page was laid out with the whole event laid out on a small scale, with a number key describing what's happening, as well as five side panels that zoom into the action was brilliant, and very unique. It was also visually very dynamic, and added another level of fun to a series that needs to be as fun as it can be.
Now this doesn't really affect the story, but there was a nice page showing Captain America, and Thor sitting in Avengers Mansion whilst the Young Avengers try and escape from their false parents. This was a really fun sequence, and although I questioned how Cap, and Thor missed the action outside, it did add some light humour to the issue. It was also nice that Cap, and Thor made another appearance (having appeared with the rest of the Avengers Unity Squad in the second issue), and although it could have been better it was still fun.
Can the Young Avengers trust Loki? Wait a minute didn't I ask this question last review? I did, but the question continues into this issue, as Loki persists in trying to persuade Wiccan to give him his powers for ten minutes. Now in a way this is a bit dull, as it's repeating something from the previous issue, but I liked how it continued as it showed the mentality of Loki, as well as continuing to ask the question whether Loki is trustworthy. Obviously the answer's no, but until the Young Avengers trust him they won't find out. I won't go right out and reveal whether they trust Loki in this issue or not, but the fact that they were considering it's interesting enough, and the build-up to making the decision was very suspenseful, and dramatic. The decision itself was also very interesting, and without spoiling, or revealing I'm looking forward to seeing how it develops in next issues conclusion.
Final Verdict
This was a surprisingly brilliant issue, and probably equal to best along with the first issue. It showed that the series could still be fun, and although it's still far from perfect, with the base of this story still being terrible, it shows hope for the future of this series, and that the next story might actually be good. I would recommend this issue, but not the series as a whole so far, as with only two good issues, as well as two poor it's probably better to either get this issue for the fun it holds, or wait for the next story to start (issue 5).
Rating: 4/5
Writer: Kieron Gillen
Artists: Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton
I was really looking forward to this series before it came out, hoping for a fun series, but to be honest it hasn't been as good as I'd hoped for, and just keeps getting worse. Hopefully it turns round though, as I'd still like this to be a good series.
Plot
Wiccan and Hulkling are stopped by Laufey when taking Loki to Asgard, getting attacked by the Frost Giant, and when Ms. America comes to help she is followed by her parents.
Review
This was another disappointing issue, and both this issue, and the entire series has been a bit slow so far. Kieron Gillen hasn't done a terrible job of this series, but he hasn't half gave us a slow story, that doesn't really show much of the characters characteristics, and that's overall a bit dull. I really didn't like Gillen's Iron Man series, as it was overall poor, and I was seriously hoping that he didn't continue that quality into this series, but somehow he has, and I don't know why, as his previous work on Loki during his Journey into Mystery run was brilliant, and one of the main reasons that I decided to get this series. I do however commend him for coming up with a fairly unique storyline, it's just a shame that it's poor, but hopefully it picks up soon. Gillen did however do a decent job with the dialogue, and although the storyline itself is dull, the dialogue between characters has been fun, and shows that with the right storyline that this series could be brilliant.
Jamie McKelvie, and Mike Norton continue to produce some brilliant artwork, and it's been one of the best things about this series so far. I'm still not 100% sure how the art is split up between the two artists, as all the art looks very similar, and without seeing either artist's previous work I can't make comparisons from that. I did however get a comment on my previous review, with the theory that McKelvie does the character art, and Norton does the background art, which kind of makes sense. Either way the characters in this series are drawn brilliantly, and although the art overall isn't the best I've ever seen, the cartoon style of it suits the fun nature that this book should have, and overall makes the series more fun. The background art is also brilliant, and has ton's of detail, but the art in general is very well detailed. The colours from Matthew Wilson are also brilliant, and they really help set the tone of the series, making the art look more fun, even if the story isn't.
There was a small battle between Wiccan, and Hulkling against Laufey at the start of this issue, and this part was actually very fun, and exciting, unlike most of the issue, but it still had it's bad points. it was really the layout, and artwork that made this sequence fun, and to be honest the dialogue was a little boring. I also felt that the fight was unrealistic, as either Laufey would kill them easily, or Wiccan would use his magic to make Laufey disappear a lot sooner than he did. Id did however like that we saw a small sequence before this were Volstagg, and Heimdall talk about them fighting, as although pointless, and unnecessary it was fun.
The fight also gets a bit poor near the end when Ms. America arrives. Don't get me wrong I was happy to see the arrival of Ms. America, as this hasn't really felt like a team book so far, and needs more characters working together, but it was the fact that she was followed by her parents that let it down. I know that this is needed to develop the story, but it didn't half take the buzz, and excitement out of the issue, making the ending of the fight a bit anticlimactic. The dialogue between Ms. America, and her parents was also a bit awkward, and although I liked how we get to see the feistiness of her, it did feel a bit unnatural, and overall made the issue even slower than it already was.
Where have Kate Bishop and Noh-Varr been? They both made an appearance in the first issue, but haven't made even small appearances since. I know that they're both meant to be making more of an appearance in the next issue, but it's still annoying that they haven't featured in the series as much so far, as Kate is my favourite character from the Young Avengers, and although I've enjoyed seeing her in Hawkeye I was hoping to see more of her in this series. Although not a huge fan I've also enjoyed seeing Noh-Varr in the Marvel Universe since he appeared in Dark Avengers, and was looking forward to seeing more of him in this series also. I also feel that their absence makes for a less team like feel to the series, and although I can see that Gillen is gradually building up the team, I'd have hoped that it'd have happened by now, but hopefully the wait till next issue pays off (but I won't hold my breath).
Can the Young Avengers trust Loki? I won't go into too much detail on this as to avoid spoilers, but basically Loki offers a solution, but needs the Young Avengers (what's there is of them so far) to do something for him. This bodes the question, can the Young Avengers trust Loki?, and the natural answer is no. No matter how hard Loki tries to be good he should never be trusted, as he's nearly always scheming, and although some may think he deserves a break once in a while, I say at the characters own peril. I do however seeing the need for the young Avengers to trust Loki to a certain point eventually, even if not completely, as for him to become a valid part of the team he'll need it, but I do look forward to the day Loki betrays them (it's bound to happen sooner or later), assuming he stays with the team long enough.
There was also a nice reference to HBO series Game of Thrones in this issue, and although it does nothing to the overall rating of this issue I felt that it was worth the mention, as being a fan of the show I found the comments quite amusing.
Final Verdict
This series has been very poor, and I desperately hope that it get's better soon. I would recommend this at your own peril, as to be honest this issue, along with the series has been poor, and I wouldn't recommend it so far, but I hope the series picks up, as it has ton's of potential. Basically I'd recommend leaving this story and seeing what the feedback is on the next one.
Rating: 3/5
Writer: Kieron Gillen
Artists: Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton
I really enjoyed the first issue of this series, and have been looking forward to this issue since. It looks like it's going to be a very fun series, and I hope that it continues to be as good, if not better than the first issue.
Plot
Wiccan notices that his spell to bring Hulkling's mother hasn't went as good as he'd hoped when she starts controlling what they do. They need help... from Loki.
Review
I have to be honest I was quite disappointed in this issue. After a decent start I was expecting the series to get better, not worse, but unfortunately it has. The reason I think that caused this issue to be poor was that it only really centred around two of the Young Avengers, three if you count Loki. I've really been looking forward to seeing them as a team, and unfortunately it hasn't happened yet. I do however have to be fair to Kieron Gillen as he's still done a decent job, and it still had some fun moments. I also think that the only real way to progress this type of story is by having a slower paced issue. I do however hope that this isn't a sign of things to come as Gillen's Iron Man series was both very poor, and very inconsistent, hence why I dropped it, and I don't want that happening to this series.
Jamie McKelvie, and Mike Norton's art was once again very good. To be honest unless it said in the credits I wouldn't notice that there was more than one artist on this series, as the artwork looks very consistent. I really think that the cartoon feel really suits this series, as it gives the fun atmosphere that the series needs. The art is also very detailed throughout, and although it's not mind-blowing, it's still very good, and very consistent. I also like the way that the emotion is shown in the artwork, as with the type of story you really need it. The colours from Matthew Wilson were also brilliant, and really helped set the tone, and mood of the series.
The story itself wasn't terrible, it just wasn't that good. I have to be honest it was the three characters featured in this that I wanted to see the most throughout the series, as although Kate Bishop is my favourite character out of the Young Avengers, she's also featured in Hawkeye. Also Wiccan, and Hulkling are the characters I want to know the best, as although I know some things I don't know everything, whereas I know more about Kate. I've also been looking forward to seeing how Loki is involved in all this, so was happy to see him involved. The lack of the other characters didn't help though, as it was really noticeable that Kate,Noh-Varr, and Miss America were missing.
I do however think that having Hulkling's "mother" as the bad guy is very interesting, as after being without her for so long to have her supposedly brought back, and find out that it's not really her, and that she's evil has to be hard to handle. I do however have some concerns about her presence though, as she's a bit creepy, and confusing at times. I do however look forward to seeing more of this.
The Uncanny Avengers also appear in this issue. Although it's been a disappointing series I have enjoyed the Uncanny Avengers as a team, and look forward to seeing more of them, so when I noticed that they would be in this issue I was very happy. It was also nice as due to Scarlet Witch being on that team it gives chance for Wiccan and her to interact, as it was revealed that she's his mother. I did however fins their appearance a bit weird, and necessary. I do however hope that Scarlet Witch is featured in the series in the future, and that it's in a longer sequence.
The boxes that Wiccan and Hulkling were put in were a bit random. As I don't know much about their past I don't exactly know what the boxes are. I can assume that they are in another dimension, and kind of like a prison, but besides that I don't know. I also found the addition of them a bit weird, and unnecessary, but if anyone understands it better than me, and in a way that makes more sense then let me know in the comments section. The only good thing about that sequence was that it was a perfect place to introduce Loki,
Seems I was talking about Loki, I might as well finish by talking more about his appearance. I won't say to much as to avoid spoilers, but as I said earlier I'm very interested to see what Loki's role in this series is. It was the addition of Loki that made me decide to get this series in the first place, as although I was interested in the team before that I was more interested after hearing that he'd be a member. Anyway his role is still a bit mysterious, but it was interesting to see him interact with Wiccan, and Hulking, and I'm looking forward to learn more about his appearance in this series down the line. Sorry if I was brief on that subject, just wanted to avoid spoilers.
Final Verdict
Although not as good as the previous issue, and slightly disappointing this was still a decent issue. I'm in two minds whether to recommend this issue or not. In hindsight I would recommend this series, as I expect it to be good in the next few issues, and it'd be a shame to miss one issue in the story. Also I felt that the story needed this slow period to help progress the story. On the other hand it'd probably be better to wait till another couple of issues are out, and see what kind of reception they get, but for anyone that bought issue 1 I'd recommend getting this.
Rating: 3.5/5
Writer: Kieron Gillen
Artists: Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton
I've never really been a fan of Young Avengers having never really read them, but after hearing that Loki would be joining them, as well as Kieron Gillen writing I thought I'd give it a try, and have been looking forward to reading it.
Plot
This issue is split into separate stories that introduce the characters, which includes former Young Avengers Wiccan, Hulkling, and Kate Bishop, and the new additions of Noh-Varr, Miss America, and Loki.
Review
Although this issue wasn't quite as good as I expected it to be, it was still a very good issue, and an excellent start to the series, introducing the characters perfectly. I loved Gillen's work on Journey Into Mystery, which also featured Loki, so expected brilliant things from this series, but after seeing his terrible work on the new Iron Man series I was no longer sure how good this series would be. Although like I said earlier this issue wasn't perfect, I still think that this type of series suits Gillen's style of writing much more than Iron Man does. I loved that Gillen took the time to introduce all the characters as for people like me, who only know a little about them, it's a brilliant way to get fully introduced without jumping straight into a story. At the same time it's not quite Young Avengers yet, as not all of the characters are together yet, but I hope that happens next issue, as at the end of the day this needs to feel like a team series.
The art from Jamie McKelvie is amazing, and although I'm not familiar with any of his work, it really suits this series. The art has a cartoon feel towards it, but it's still got ton's of detail, and I feel that the look is perfect for this type of series,giving the fun vibe that's expected in a fun series. McKelvie also does a brilliant job of drawing people, and although it'snot the best art I've ever seen, it is still very good, and consistent, with all the panels having tremendous detail. He also draws the characters emotions, and expressions perfectly, as you can really feel the emotion throughout, and especially in the sequence featuring Wiccan, and Hulkling. Besides great detail McKelvie also draws some amazing action sequences, and I really think that his art will make this series phenomenal, and hope he stays on for a long time.
The story was a little over the place to introduce all the characters, but the issue starts with Kate Bishop wake up in Noh-Varr's house in space. I thought this was a brilliant sequence, as although we get to see Kate get involved in the series we also get to see some development in Noh-Varr's characteristics. I've been enjoying seeing Kate in the current Hawkeye series, and am happy to see her in this series, but it was whilst reading I became more interested in Noh-Varr. Although he's made many appearances over the last few years, mainly in Avengers series he has always been a bit mysterious, so to see some character development was nice. I especially liked how he was staying near earths he could continue listening to music.
The most interesting sequence in this issue however had to be the sequence featuring Wiccan, and Hulkling. As I said earlier I'm not overly familiar with the Young Avengers, or it's characters, and I was surprised to find out Wiccan, and Hulkling were lovers. Don't get me wrong I'm not against same sex relationships, and it wouldn't be the first time I've seen it in comics, but all the same it was still a surprise. Moving that aside, I felt that this was a very moving, and emotional sequence, as Wiccan was upset that Hulkling was out fighting crime, as apparently the former Young Avengers agreed to stop being super heroes. The thing that made this sequence emotional however was how Hulkling went on to talk about him not having parents, and that he fell in love with Wiccan because he was a super hero. It's hard to explain the actual emotion, but this showed that due to having no parents, that the only things Hulking cared about were Wiccan, and being a super hero.
The sequence I expected to be the best in this issue was the meeting between Loki, and Miss America. This was what was featured in Marvel NOW! Point One, and due to loving the mini sequence in that I expected it to be the best in this issue. It was however still a very good sequence, and the only reason it wasn't, was due to the emotion in the Wiccan/Hulkling sequence. As I said earlier, it was Loki's involvement in this series that got me interested in the first place, and after seeing him in this issue I wasn't disappointed. Gillen continued writing Loki as well as he did in JIM, but this time he added a bit of humor to him. I especially liked how how he described his brother Thor as being fond of his hammer. It will be interesting to see how Loki fits into this team, and I'm also interested to see if Thor will ever make an appearance, as Loki caused Thor quite a lot of grief last time we saw him. I'll also be looking forward to seeing some more development into the Miss America character, as besides her being extremely angry with Loki there wasn't much of it in this issue.
Final Verdict
This was a very good issue, and I still have high hopes for this series. The issue itself was far from perfect, but it was a great start, and makes it easy for brand new readers to like this series. I would highly recommend this issue, and am extremely looking forward to the next issue.
Rating: 4/5
